This cottage cheese frosting is naturally sweetened and lighter than traditional cream cheese frosting. It's creamy, has more protein than regular frosting, and needs just 5 minutes of hands-on time. A Baltic staple reimagined as a simple everyday topping, with a vanilla base and four variations: lemon, warm spiced, chai and lingonberry.
Taste your cottage cheese before you start. If it tastes salty, rinse it well under cold water before draining. Different brands vary quite a bit.
Drain the cottage cheese in a fine-mesh strainer for at least 1 hour. Don't skip this step! Undrained cottage cheese will make the frosting too watery to use.
In a food processor, blend the drained cottage cheese, cream cheese, maple syrup or honey, vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste, spices, and lemon juice (if using) until completely smooth (about 1-2 minutes). A hand mixer works in a pinch but may leave small curds in the finished frosting.
Transfer to a bowl and refrigerate for at least 1 hour before using to firm up.
For the lingonberry version, stir the jam into the chilled vanilla frosting. Don’t blend it, or you’ll lose the streaks.
Apply to completely cooled muffins, cupcakes or cake.
Notes
Tips for the Best Cottage Cheese Frosting
Use full-fat cottage cheese and cream cheese for the best flavor, but it will work with low fat if you choose.
If you can still see curds, keep blending. Scrape down the sides once and give it another minute.
Use vanilla bean paste if you can, it really does make a difference for this cottage cheese icing recipe.
Like all dairy frostings, this one doesn't love the heat. Even with powdered sugar, it will soften if it sits out in a warm kitchen. Frost your muffins or cake straight from the fridge, keep them cool until serving, and refrigerate leftovers promptly.
Storage:
Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 4 days.
Do NOT freeze. It does not defrost well and loses its shape.